Refugees rights - UNHCR

We Want Education: Organizing classes for asylum seekers in the middle of the nowhere

No Comments 31 August 2014

Sara Stern is the director of The Schoolhouse, an adult education program for African asylum seekers currently running programming out of Tel Aviv as well as Holot, the “open” detention facility in Israel’s Negev desert where thousands of asylum seekers are currently detained.  Although we object to the indeterminate detention of asylum seekers in Israel without cause, and hope that soon Holot will be shut down, with its residents  freed, we understand the practical importance of a program like this in the meanwhile for the well-being of the community. 


By: Sara Stern

”halow plase i wont to lerning to english longoj so u mast to halp wther is the adres of these school.” – message received on The Schoolhouse facebook page

English language and education are consistently  expressed by the refugee-asylum seeker community in Israel as significantly important  towards making an impact on their lives and their future.

The first time I really became aware of this was in 2008 when I was volunteering with the newly arrived Sudanese refugees in Jerusalem, and we had a meeting asking “How else can we help?” The response was loud and clear: We want Education.

After more than two years of developing adult education for the refugee-asylum seeker population in Tel Aviv through the framework of The Schoolhouse, students began to receive summons to the Holot “open” detention center. Our goal became clear: to implement an education program in the remote detention prison out in the middle of the Southern desert. I wrote a proposal for a broad education program serving the full inmate population, but many obstacles stood in the way. We sought cooperation or support from the IPS (Israel Prison System) and the Ministry of Education, but this turned into a frustrating challenge with no positive results to come so far. Meanwhile, with lack of activity or programming provided in the detention center itself,  and the prohibition to work, some 12-15 Holot inmates began teaching English inside the detention walls to their peers whose English backgrounds were less strong. This is what they chose to do with their time.

It took seven months until the first English class opened for 25 students, and in a few weeks, a Teacher Training program for these inexperienced yet highly motivated teachers will also commence.  The classes have been organized The Schoolhouse together with the nearby Nitzana youth village and the education activists in Holot, funded by UNHCR.

We face many challenges including finding qualified teachers who can commit to working  in such a remote location, transportation for students to Nitzana, where the classes are held, locating funding for additional teachers so that we might open additional classes, and recruiting volunteers who can assist in the classes, as the detention center is at least a half hour away from any city.  Additionally, the future of Holot remains unknown, a court decision is expected this month which will decide its legality, but despite all this we move forward, the threat of encroaching hopelessness too strong on our friends.

Students in the English class currently offered to Holot inmates. The class is held at the nearby Nitzana Youth Village, serves the highest level students, and is filled to capacity.

Students studying in the English class currently offered to Holot inmates by The Schoolhouse together with the nearby Nitzana youth village. The class is filled to capacity and in the next few weeks, a teacher-training course will be opened as well.

As I reviewed the results of English language assessments we gave to these Holot students joining the English class, I became filled with awe and inspiration. And this is fundamentally what again and again fuels me to do what I do.

The assessments themselves, I have to admit, were quite dry, and also difficult.

But as I reviewed the completed tests,  one by one, it was astonishing to see what burst through these dry papers. The motivation, strength, desire to learn and move forward, to make something meaningful of their lives, to contribute to society and give to others, to become leaders and make a social, just or educational impact. This is what I read in between and directly on the lines of their answers, sometimes regardless of the questions. Yet,  these are the people we are putting behind bars.zoey group 3 first week

At The Schoolhouse when students come to register for evening classes in Tel Aviv, they fill out a questionare and we ask a few questions such as: “Why is it important for you to study English?” and “What do you want to do with your future?” I’ve heard and read many variations of the answer “I want to go back to my country and help my people” or “I want to influence my government from within” or “I want to become a teacher,” or “lawyer” or “doctor” or “leader”.

There must be an alternative, humane solution for our refugee-established country, the country that was built with the very hands and minds of courageous and strong people yearning for independence, freedom, and life without persecution,  individuals who fought so hard not only for their own survival, but also for a better future.

We must have another system for dealing with other refugees and asylum seekers who walk all the way to our borders and ask to be let in, braving hardships of the journey and such immense risk. Likewise for migrants who seek escape from poverty, inequality and lack of opportunity.

Maybe one idea is to turn the center into less of a detention prison and more into an absorption center, serving those who need the support and at the same time are more likely to fall burden on Israeli society. They would be permitted to work, being productive for themselves and surrounding society and an education program would provide practical and transferable language and vocational skills. At the same time,  their refugee claims would be reviewed and alternative long term solutions would be researched. You say this may be costly? Check the numbers on the money invested so far to build and operate Holot as it is.

The truth is – and I speak from experience – that if the people themselves were consulted with we’d all be amazed as to the intelligent and innovative solutions they’d come up with and suggest, taking into consideration not only themselves but also the politics and complexity posed on Israel as a state.

I’ll  leave you with a short composition written by Schoolhouse student Hussein from Sudan, at the opening of the Jewish year in 2013:

This year is going to be better than last year.
I’m going to improve my life.  
I am also going to improve my English more and more, in some way.
 Sometimes  I see myself running, but why am I running?
I am running for life.  
I just want to be somebody. I don’t know if I can. 
I will try to have a better life, no reason just to run away.
 I just move on, I can’t sit and feel sorry for myself. 
Life is not that bad. There will be good and bad times, either way it’s life.
 I would like to change my life.


Sara Stern is the founder and director of The Schoolhouse. To learn more or volunteer in the developing education program for Holot inmates, contact her at /

 All opinions expressed here are those of the writer, and not necessarily those of Rabbis for Human Rights.

Additional information on asylum seekers and refugees in Israel

Parasha / E-Letter

Weekly parasha: Pursuing unity and harmony within Justice

No Comments 27 August 2014

In Parashat Shoftim, Rabbi Mira Raz examines justice and law, showing us how in order to establish a legal system that fosters not only a society that is stable and ordered, but also a society where the individual is free to live a meaningful life, we must strive to  create balance between justice, legislator and executer, as well as between the material world and the unseen world. Continue Reading

General, Occupied Territories, Reflections from RHR Rabbis & Staff

On Rosh Khodesh & the Ceasefire: A meditation to open ourselves to the power of Elul

No Comments 26 August 2014

On Tuesday and Wednesday, August 26th and 27th,  we mark the new Jewish month of Elul, a month set apart from the others as a time of deep soul searching and repentance in preparation for the upcoming Jewish High Holidays. The marking of the new month, referred to as Rosh Khodesh Elul, this year has coincided with the announcing of a new ceasefire agreement between Hamas and Israel, effectively (hopefully) ending  Operation Protective Edge in the Gaza Strip.  Continue Reading

Parasha / E-Letter

Weekly parasha: Its ways are ways of pleasantness

No Comments 21 August 2014

In this week’s parasha, Rabbi Uri Regev considers the milieu of teachings existing in Judaism on assimilation, eventually resting confidently in Judaism’s ability to flourish and handle well the challenges it is presented with by virtue of its righteousness and goodness. Continue Reading

Reflections from RHR Rabbis & Staff

My Enemies Are Fear, Hatred and Greed: By Rabbi Emma Sham-Ba Ayalon

1 Comment 20 August 2014

Rabbi Emma Sham-Ba Ayalon reflects on her recent experience in a week-long  intentional “peace camp” together with Israeli, Palestinian, and international activists, and explains how her participation moved her to respond to a message of war with a message of love. Continue Reading

Occupied Territories, Reflections from RHR Rabbis & Staff

Gaza: Strive for peace and pursue it: By Rabbi Yehiel Grenimann

No Comments 20 August 2014

Rabbi Yehiel Grenniman, director of our human rights in the occupied territories department, recently had his thoughts on the Gaza war published by CNN International.

Rabbi Yehiel Grenimann at the Tag Meir demonstration against vengeance and violence in Jerusalem

Rabbi Yehiel Grenimann at the Tag Meir demonstration against vengeance and violence in Jerusalem following the revenge murder of 16 year old Muhammad Abu Khdeir



My son has recently been released from active reserve duty in the Israel Defense Forces in Gaza, and the two sides are again talking about a serious ceasefire. I am relieved to have my son back and to see that we are talking instead of shooting, and pray that this latest round of negotiations succeeds in bringing us stability and progress towards peace.

Click to continue reading

851x315_e copy



His memory is most definitely a blessing: Rabbi Ascherman on the passing of Leonard Fein z”l

1 Comment 18 August 2014

Last week, Leonard Fein z”l passed away at eighty years old. Leonard was a great Jewish American thinker, doer and writer whose influence on progressive Judaism will echo for years and years to come.  Rabbi Ascherman, president and senior rabbi of RHR, remembers him as a supportive, insightful and inspiring influence: Continue Reading

Justice in Israel, Reflections from RHR Rabbis & Staff

Don’t let the most vulnerable of society pay for “Protective Edge”

No Comments 18 August 2014

Operation Protective Edge cost Israel 4.3 billion, while  projected total cost has been estimated at NIS 8.5 billion. Who ends up really paying the price? Whose security is neglected over the cost of national security?

Sharon GuarihnI sraelSocialTV

Sharon Guarihn: “Security is not just about national security, it’s about economic security…”

By: Rabbi Idit Lev

The Committee to Fight Poverty (Alaluf Committee) recommended allocating NIS 8 billion Shekels (about 2.3 billon USD) to go towards poverty, in particular for housing aid and increasing of social welfare. This could reduce the poverty rate by ten percent in five years. Meanwhile it seems that economic and military rehabilitation following the Protective Edge operation in Gaza will push aside implementing these recommendations. And who pays the price?  The citizens living in poverty, of course. Listen to Sharon Guarihn’s call, a citizen of Hadera with a monthly salary of 2200 Shekels (634 USD):

“Security is not just about national security, it’s about economic security, and it’s starting to be about nutritional security, basic security of kids who don’t have it; they don’t have after-school activities or a proper school to go to. How can we live like this? This is not economic welfare or security. My boy is afraid that tomorrow they’ll throw him out of his home because we can’t afford rent. Wake up people, wake up!”

Report by Israel Social TV featuring Rabbi Idit Lev and Rabbi Sigal Asher of RHR’s Rights Center in Hadera [Hebrew]


RHR’s response to the findings of the Alaluf Committee

All posts from our Socioeconomic Justice in Israel Department

Occupied Territories, Reflections from RHR Rabbis & Staff

Human rights organizations and Gaza: Breaking down the myths

No Comments 17 August 2014

There are many false myths regarding the positions of human rights organizations on the current operation in Gaza, as well as the ones which preceded it. These myths are disseminated by all sorts of organizations with the goal of undermining the legitimacy of human rights organizations in Israel. We thought we would make some order in this mess. We cannot speak for all human rights organizations, only for Rabbis for Human Rights, though we believe that a significant portion of what is written here reflects, to a large extent, the positions of many organizations as well as the spirit of international humanitarian law. International humanitarian law coincidentally or not so coincidentally overlaps important Jewish principles, and principles of common sense,  facilitating a smart balance between security needs/military considerations and concern for the civilian population on the other side. Continue Reading

Occupied Territories, Reflections from RHR Rabbis & Staff

Questioning not if the army is moral, but if the policy is moral

2 Comments 17 August 2014

As part of RHR’s effort to engage in a dialogue with the Israeli settler community, the following opinion piece on the IDF and morality will be published in a local print paper in the Israeli settlement Ariel shortly. Please continue to look  for additional pieces in this series alongside the responses by the settler communities themselves. Continue Reading

Join Us »

Share Online

© 2014 Rabbis for Human Rights. Powered by WordPress.