General, Justice in Israel, Justice in Israel-Negev Bedouin

What is the Begin/Prawer Plan?

27 Comments 03 May 2013

The Ministerial Committee on Legislative Affairs is set to discuss the Bill on the Arrangement of Bedouin Settlement in the Negev on Monday 6 May. The Bedouin community and human rights organisations strongly object to the bill and want it removed from the Knesset’s and government’s agenda. The bill is based on the Begin Plan, approved by the government on January 27, 2013, which effectively constitutes a modified version of the Prawer Plan for Bedouin settlement in the Negev, approved by the government on September 11, 2011.


Today the Bedouin number 210,000. About 120,000 live in seven Bedouin towns established by the State. Most of the towns suffer heavily from poverty and unemployment resulting from discrimination and their residents’ severance from traditional livelihood and sources of income. The rest of the community  – around 90,000, live in 11 villages currently undergoing recognition, plus 35 more villages with more than 500 inhabitants each. The State of Israel does not recognise these  35 villages. These 46 villages together constitute around 5% of the entire land of the Negev. 

These Israeli citizens in unrecognised villages are denied their most basic rights: their villages are not connected to the state’s water and sewer systems nor to its electrical grid; education and health services are only partially provided to them, and are inadequate; and the state refuses to recognise villagers’ historical claims of ancestral ownership of the land.

Until 1948 the Negev served as home to 65,000-100,000 Bedouin who inhabited and worked somewhere between 2 and 3 million dunams of land. After the war only about 10% of the population remained, under a military regime. In the 1970’s the State of Israel allowed the Bedouin to submit claims of land ownership. The Bedouin asserted they owned about 1.5 million dunams of land. Of those, about 500,000 dunams of pastureland were not granted recognition; different sources disagree over the exact total and the number of dunams formalized through court rulings. The estimates range from 200,000 to 350,000 dunam. In some cases they received compensation, but in the vast majority of cases they were not given the right to remain on the lands they had claimed to own, and many of the resolutions were forced on the Bedouin. About 650,000 dunams of land remain unresolved.

The desire to develop the Northern Negev prompted the government of Israel to recognize the need to resolve the ownership of the lands.

In 2008 a committee under a retired judge, Eliezer Goldberg, determined that historical Bedouin rights to the land must be recognised. A series of recommendations were made but the government did not ratify these and instead established the Praver Committee in 2009, which was to oversee implementation of the Goldberg Committee report. The Praver committee altered both its approach to the issue and its recommendations. According to the Praver proposal the Bedouin would only receive 180,000-200,000 dunams, whereas their claims cover approximately 600,000. About 40,000 Bedouin will be removed from their villages if the proposal is adopted. A reading of the Praver Committee report indicates that the committee did not involve the Bedouin community in determining its fate; it did not even hear its claims.

As a result of vehement public criticism of the Praver report, former Minister Benny Begin embarked on a “listening mission” aimed at fixing the Praver report. The Begin Outline was approved by the government on 27 January 2013, but despite its softer rhetoric, the latest report does not contain any redress for the government’s unwillingness to recognize the 36 unrecognized Bedouin villages and to fairly resolve the land ownership claims of Bedouin citizens whose property was appropriated by the State.

The bill outlines a framework for the implementation of government policies toward the Bedouin population on two separate issues: (1) the evacuation of unrecognized villages in the Negev, and (2) the settlement of ownership of lands in the Negev.  The bill is based on the absolute negation of the Bedouin population’s rights to property and historical ties to the land, in violation of the residents of the unrecognized villages’ basic rights.

Like Prawer, the Begin Plan is also based on the notion that Bedouin are “squatters,” ignoring the fact that most of the villages have been in existence in their current location since before the establishment of the State of Israel. Other villages were established by government transfer during the period of martial law.

What will happen if the plan is implemented?

The plan will lead to the uprooting and forcible eviction of dozens of villages and 30-40,000 Bedouin residents, who will be stripped of their property and their historical land rights. Thousands of families will be condemned to poverty and unemployment. The communal life and social fabric of these villages will be destroyed. Like its precursor, the current plan also seeks to restrict the Bedouin to a specific area and to forcibly apply this policy.

A fair arrangement is needed to benefit all the Negev residents

A significant choice now confronts the State of Israel. At stake is not only the fate of about 40,000 Bedouin threatened with expulsion from their homes, but the future of all the Negev inhabitants. The decision before us is whether to perpetuate and exacerbate the tension and sense of deprivation already worsening the situation in the Negev, or to arrive at a just resolution that will allow closer relations and promote growth and development of the area. 

A just and feasible solution means, first and foremost, recognizing the fact that the Bedouin in the unrecognized villages are citizens with equal rights

  • The demands of the Negev Bedouin population

The Bedouin community constitutes 30% of the Negev population, and their demands involve only 5.4% of its land. For comparison, the population density in all the unrecognized Bedouin villages is 6.3 times that of the adjacent Bnei Shimon Regional Council. The Bedouin occupy much less space in proportion to their numbers even if all their demands are met!

The time has come for an equitable resolution of Bedouin rights in the Negev. Any worthy resolution must preserve the following principles:

  • It will be arrived at only with real involvement from the Bedouin community institutions.
  • Full recognition for all existing villages, even if that means altering the national zoning plan.
  • Acceptance of the ownership claims made in the 1970’s.
  • Diversity of settlement types, not just towns or large villages.
  • Integration of the community in planning and finding solutions.
  • Developing the Negev equally – for all its residents.

Sign a letter to the Ministers calling on them to stop the Begin/Praver Proposal

Your Comments

27 Comments so far

  1. Councillor Jonathan Bloch says:

    It would be an absolute outrage if this plan went ahead

  2. Sharon Bernstein says:

    Please find some way to not commit yet another outrage against yet another group of people —find a way to a just solution. Please.

  3. Toby Furash says:

    Please preserve the Bedouin lands, their rights, customs and peoplehood of all Bedouin persons. This is essential for all Bedouins and all Israelis.

  4. Jeromé Freedman says:

    “Tsedek, tsedek tirdof.” “Justice, justice shall you pursue.” [Deut.XVI, 20]

    “Ve’ahavta lrayecha kamocha”. “And you shall love your neighbour as yourself.” [Rabbi Akiva]

    “To be just is to demand justice for other peoples as well as your own.” [Rabbi John D. Rayner z”l]

  5. Doris Ghannam says:

    Please don’t forget to mention the role of the JNF / KKL, its Blueprint Negev programme, for more information see The Negev Coexistence Forum:
    The threat for the Beouins in the Naqab with expulsion etc. started before the Prawer Plan / Begin Plan came up!

  6. Liliana Trodler says:

    It looks as we want to make the same mistakes that were done to the Native American populations. Justice is the opposite of taking vengeance on the less powerful, justice is what we were commanded to do.

  7. Albert Einstein writing to Chaim Weitzmann
    “If we are not able to find a way to honest cooperation
    and honest pacts with the Arabs, then we have learned
    nothing during our two thousand years of suffering…
    Without honest cooperation with the Arabs there is no
    peace and no security.”

  8. Barbara C. Felton says:

    Will the Zionists ever learn – they practice exactly what was done to them in the past.
    And who knows, perhaps this could happen again if they pursue their unconscionable tactics.

  9. Angelika Schneider says:

    It is very hard to watch the end of the film Fiddler on the Roof (Anatevka) with the expulsion of the Jews from a village where they have lived for generations, and to believe that Jews anywhere in the world today could force the same fate on their Bedouin neighbours.

  10. Samuel Stayton says:

    Israel should not steal land from the Bedouins.

  11. Camilla Jones says:

    Israel has lost it’s moral authority and transformed itself into a world class bully.
    ‘Remember the Holocaust’ becomes meaningless.

  12. Edmund Tomey says:

    Israel is yet putting another obstacle in the path of the world accepting the legitimate existence of the state of Israel. How many times can this situation of Israels stealing Palestinian land be tolerated

  13. Edmund Tomey says:

    Israel is yet putting another obstacle in the path of the world accepting the legitimate existence of the state of Israel. How many times can this situation of Israels stealing Palestinian land be tolerated

  14. Hao says:

    Access keys Microsoft Office 2010 have been invented Office 2010 which allow you to focus on a speficic part of a page Microsoft Office 2007 to make Microsoft Office Online pages Microsoft Office easy to navigate by keyboard outlook 2010. Access keys are key combinations office 2010 microsoft which move the focus to a wanted outlook 2010 key element. Microsoft office 2007 s Outlook is included by email client Basic ms office 2010, Standard, Professional Plus Office 2007, and the Basic edition has only download microsoft office 2010 omitted enterprise PowerPoint. These access keys are designed to download office 2010 work with Netscape Navigator Office 2010 download and Microsoft Internet Explorer microsoft word. If you are using other Web browsers or earlier versions of office 2010 professional Internet Explorer, access keys Office 2010 free may not work Microsoft outlook any more ms office 2007. And, the applications office 2010 home which are included in Microsoft Office 2007 vary that Microsoft Office 2010 key is according to the package you select office professional 2010. In the page footer, move office 2007 key the focus to the Accessibility link, if you have changed your display options in Windows to use high contrast MS office 2010 key, Internet Explorer will Office 2010 key pay no attention to your Windows settings Microsoft Office 2010 free and display the page just as it was created originally microsoft office 2007 home. Let’s have a look, in Microsoft Word 2007, people who use it will can see how many styles MS office 2010 download in it, fonts, when you are clicking the Change Styles icon Microsoft outlook 2010 and browsing by a micro office 2010 box text sizes Microsoft Office 2010 download you will found it in their document.

  15. Very nice post. I simply stubled upon your weblog and
    wanted to mention that I’ve truly loved surfing around your wewblog posts.
    After all I will be subbscribing in your feed and I’m hoping you wrikte oncee more soon!

  16. The man or woman who ɦas died haas tο be buried as shortly аs possible and іn the course of daylight.
    Imprved tо obtain а harmless place to ǥo too that іs not also far
    absent. Alloit ѕome time for peace аnd snooze as suƄstantially as
    yoս сɑn.

  17. Good information. Lucky me I found your site by chance (stumbleupon).
    I have saved as a favorite for later!

  18. Hello there! Do you know if thney make any plugins to help with Search Engine Optimization?
    I’m trying tto geet myy blog to rank for skme targeted keywords but I’m not seeing very
    good success. If you know of any please share. Appreciate

  19. Hello there, You have done a fantastic job. I’ll certainly digg it and personally recommend to my friends.

    I am confident they will be benefited from this
    web site.

  20. I am new to blogging. How do I add a subscribe function to my site so new post will go to their email?.


  1. PALESTINE NEWS | May 3, 2013 | Occupied Palestine | فلسطين - May 4, 2013
  2. Destroying the Lives of 40,000 Bedouin Israeli Citizens | Seven Months in Tel Aviv - May 5, 2013

    […] this on to others who might be interested in stopping this legislation. We only have 24 hours. Click here for a history of how this particular plan was […]

  3. Muftah » Dispossession of the Israeli Bedouin - May 24, 2013

    […] 120,000 Bedouin already live in state-approved townships in Israel. Unemployment and poverty are rampant in these […]

  4. Vayishlach: Politics before People always leads to disaster | rabbisylviarothschild - November 11, 2013
  5. Coalition Protests Bedouin Resettlement Plan | Partners for Progressive Israel - January 21, 2015

    […] Background Paper from the Recognition Forum: The Coalition of Organizations for Recognition of the Unrecognized Negev Bedouin Villages […]

Share your view

Post a comment

© 2018 Rabbis for Human Rights. Powered by WordPress.